Batting exit velocity leaders, pitchers, minimum 10 non-bunt balls in play
1. Ross, 93.5 mph
2. Lester, 92.5 mph
3. James Shields, 90.6 mph
4. Carlos Martinez, 90.2 mph
5. Shelby Miller, 89.8 mph
We absolutely had to dig into that deeper, and so we did. The lesson learned is one we've been touching on since the early days of Statcast™: Exit velocity is cool, but it's only part of the story. Launch angle is a big part of it too.
Let's explain: Launch angle may sound fancy, but it's simply measuring the vertical angle of the ball off the bat. For example, if you were to hit the ball at 90 degrees, that'd be straight up -- a popup. We've been considering grounders to be 10 degrees or under, flies to be 25 and over, and line drives to be in between.
It matters, a lot, as shown by the embedded tweet below showing batting averages at various launch angles. If the ball comes off your bat at between 10 and 14 degrees, you're hitting .775, which is to say that it lands for a hit more than three-quarters of the time. If you hit it at an angle higher than 50 degrees, which is when flies turn into popups, you're toast -- just 80 of the 4,841 balls hit like that turned into hits, a .016 batting average.
It's a good lesson in how exit velocity and launch angle go hand-in-hand. By itself, launch angle can tell you a lot, as the numbers above show, but not everything. By itself, exit velocity can tell you a lot -- it correlates well to offensive success -- but again, not everything.
All of which leads us back to Lester, and how he could have hit the ball so hard without finding much success. (He ended up with four hits on the season in 71 plate appearances, a .065/.108/.065 line.) Part of it is that, like many pitchers, contact was an issue -- Lester's 42.3 percent strikeout rate was above the 37.7 percent average for pitchers.
But more importantly, it's because 19 of Lester's 24 tracked batted balls failed to get above 7 degrees of launch angle. Sixteen of those 19 failed to even achieve positive launch angle, which is to say that he pounded the ball into the ground constantly. Even Lester's first career hit, against former teammate John Lackey, came at an angle of -2.8 degrees, though it was well placed and cracked at 92 mph:
Now, compare Lester's launch angle and exit velocity to those of Ross and Bumgarner, 2015's two best-hitting pitchers by traditional measures.
Ross: 93.5 mph, 10.6 degrees
Lester: 92.5 mph, -1.4 degrees
Bumgarner: 89.1 mph, 12.5 degrees
And there's your difference right there, along with superior contact rate. Hitting the ball hard is a very good thing to do, but if it's always going to be on the ground, then you're relying upon a whole lot of luck to get hits. In Lester's case, that luck never arrived until he managed to put one literally off Lackey's leg.
Think about it this way: Lester hit seven balls at 100 mph or more, topping out at 104.8 mph off Anthony DeSclafani in June. On average, balls hit at 100 mph or more turn into hits 61 percent of the time (or a .611 batting average, if you prefer). For Lester? Just one did, or a .142 average on those balls. Grounders just aren't a good value bet, if you can avoid them.
Despite the record he doesn't want, Lester was once a high school outfielder who was good enough with the bat that he would have made the pros as a position player. We never got to see that bat show up over nearly a decade in the American League, and the 0-for-66 streak would have you believe he doesn't know what he's doing at the plate. Not so, as the exit velocity shows. Lester can hit with plenty of authority, just not with enough angle. Hitting the ball hard is great. Hitting it hard to the right spot is better. Sometimes, it's crucial.